One of the mainstays in the menu of restaurants in the Tagaytay and Batangas aras is tawilis. Often, deep fried to a crisp so that every part, bones and head included, is edible.
Tawilis is a sardine but it is a class all its own because it is the only member of the family Clupeidae that is known to exist entirely in freshwater. Tawilis is only found in Taal Lake. And the lake itself is part of the mystery of tawilis. There is some evidence that Taal Lake was once partly filled with salt water as it was once connected to the South China Sea. When the connection was closed as topography changed over the centuries, the lake turned purely freshwater and it is said that many salt water animals adapted to their new habitat.
Hence, an explanation as to why a sardine became a freshwater fish. So surmises Thomas Hargrove in his book The Mysteries of Taal. Hargrove was obsessed with Taal for a long, long time. If the name sounds familiar, his kidnapping which he chronicled in a book became the movie Proof of Life starring Russell Crowe and Meg Ryan.
Question: If the tawilis is only found in Taal Lake, which is a very small lake, then supply must be very limited. Why is it that tawilis is widely sold in almost every market in Metro Manila at very cheap prices? That doesn’t really make sense in view of the law of supply and demand. Is it possible that they are not some other kind of and are just being passed off as real tawilis? Are we being duped?
Onion bread
yumi
11/25/2010 at 2:28 pmyes! some fish looks like tawilis, there
are fake ones and some vendors in the market, tag them as tawilis. so buy from a reputable suki.
i forgot the name of the so called impostor fish , i think it starts with the letter S. ill keep you posted.
hehehehhe! kawawa naman yung fish na di tawilis hindi naman niya fault. hehehe..
hope to hear from you connie.
monako
11/25/2010 at 5:37 pmyes, most of the tawilis being sold in Manila is FAKE. They are actually silinyasi (not sure about the spelling). Others call it tinyasi. It looks like tawilis except the scales are smoother and not as delicious.
Connie
11/26/2010 at 11:47 amThat was what I’ve told — so many fakes. I think even in Tagaytay restos they’re trying to pass some other fish as tawilis.
Mary Ann
11/22/2012 at 8:36 pmIf one does not have a discriminating palate one can be fooled. Real tawilis do not have shiny scale. Tawilis has a very distinct and deep nutty flavour especially when smoked.
Back living in the Philippines, I buy tinapang tawilis in Bucutan market, but my suki, comes all the way from Tagayaty only on Saturdays – and sometimes not.
This is the real McCoy …..
Nina Natalia Bautista
08/26/2013 at 12:28 pmYup, those are fakes. Tawilis are hard to transport because they spoil and nadudurog easily. Tawilis has a distinct smell, you’ll know if it’s fake. :)