Penne with portobello mushrooms Penne with portobello mushrooms

Inspired by the pasta with white sauce that accompanied my chicken lunch at La Maison, the discovery that La Maison’s pasta was made with portobello mushrooms came as a coincidence. I had never eaten portobello mushrooms before (it used to be hard to find them in local supermarkets) so when I saw trays and trays of the stuff at Shopwise, I bought a 220-gram pack. Six pieces in all. I minced three and mixed them with ground chicken to make burgers for last night’s dinner and, as I was eating my burger, the distinct flavor of the portobellos suddenly reminded me of the pasta at La Maison. Ergo, for lunch today, I boiled some penne and went about my attempt to recreate that wonderful creamy sauce that I enjoyed so much.

Serves 3.

120 g. of penne (or your pasta shape of choice), cooked al dente

To make the creamy portobello mushroom sauce

3 portobello mushrooms, about 100 grams
2 tbsps. of butter
2 tbsps. of olive oil
3 tbsps. of chopped basil
1 tbsp. of finely minced garlic
1 c. of cream
1/4 c. of milk
salt and pepper, to taste
4 tbsps. of grated sharp cheddar cheese, plus more to garnish

Make the sauce as soon as you start cooking the pasta. You really want the sauce to sit for a while to allow the flavors to blend together.

Wipe the mushrooms with paper towels, cut each in half then slice — about 1/4-inch thick slices is good.

Heat the butter and olive oil in a pan. Add the basil and garlic and cook gently for about 30 seconds. Add the portobello mushrooms and cook, stirring, for another 30 seconds. Pour in the cream and milk. Season with salt and pepper. As soon as the mixture bubbles, turn off the heat. Stir in the cheese until it melts. Cover the pan and let the sauce sit there until the pasta is ready.

When the pasta is done, drain and add to the sauce. Toss to coast each noodle well. Ladle into bowls or plates, top with more grated cheese and enjoy!


  1. misao says

    hi ms. connie,

    in which shopwise branch do you go to? is it in antipolo or in libis? as those two are probably the nearest in your place. just asking… para alam ko kung san ako makakabili ng good variety of mushrooms, without going to farmers or megamall.

  2. says

    A friend of mine suggested this but haven’t been able to do this kse ang mahal nga ng portobellos. However, this season, i can probably make an exception. Kakagana din naman kse ng photo eh. :)

  3. Pearl says

    I love portobellos in sandwiches with roasted vegetables..yummy! My niece also said it is best roasted with butter and herbs. For pasta, I will try your recipe, with bacon.

  4. jam says

    ms. connie, ask ko lang po kung yung sharp cheddar ay pareho ng strong cheddar? yun kasi nakita ko sa grocery eh. thanks po!

  5. Mia says

    Hi, I just bought a bag of pre-washed, pre-sliced portabellos and have been using them in curry, but this recipe looks fantastic.

    Just wondering though, I only have dried basil, would that work? And if so, roughly how much should I use?

  6. Susan says

    Hi Connie,

    will it make a difference if i use another type of mushroom, let’s say
    champignons? i’m not sure if we have sharp cheddar here in our supermarket but we do have old cheese, would that be good, too?

    • Connie says

      “will it make a difference if i use another type of mushroom”

      Mushrooms have different flavors but there’s no reason why other varieties won’t be good for this dish.

      I do not know what “old cheese” is but any hard salty cheese should be good.

Commenting Guidelines:

1. Read the post carefully before asking questions.
2. Stay on topic; this is not an "anything goes" forum.
3. If you're on a recipe page and you want to substitute an ingredient or a procedure, please don't ask if it will work. I cannot make a guess about something I have not tried.
4. Self-promotion is not allowed. You will be blacklisted and your comment will be deleted.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *