Causes of the common cold and other old wives’ tales: the Vitamin C angle

My nose is still stuffy as I write this, I’ve been nursing a cold for days and I figured I’d read about the common cold and find out why it is often associated with Vitamin C deficiency. The reading started by revisiting something I wrote five years ago about some fantastic theories on what causes the common cold and the comments from readers were replete with all kinds of weird superstitions. Read it, and the comments, and be entertained.

But even before going into the Vitamin C deficiency angle, let me start by saying that the common cold is caused by a virus (it is a different virus if the cold is a precursor to influenza) which infects the upper respiratory tract. A virus. Despite being called the COLD, it is not caused by exposure to cold weather or by ingesting large amounts of something cold especially during cold weather — like eating too much ice cream when it’s raining cats and dogs. We’re smack in the middle of summer here in the tropics and I have a bad cold.

Moreover, the viruses that cause the common cold are not airborne. In short, when someone infected with a cold sneezes or coughs without covering his mouth, the persons around him will not catch the virus that way. It is spread via physical contact.

The primary means of spreading a cold is through hand-to-hand contact or from objects that have been touched by someone with a cold.

The typical transmission occurs when a cold sufferer rubs his or her nose and then, shortly thereafter, shakes hands with someone who, in turn, touches his or her own nose or eyes.

Alternatively, virus transmission often occurs via doorknobs and other hard surfaces, such as subway handrails, grocery carts, office telephones, and computer keyboards. [Source]

Now, the Vitamin C angle. Why is it that when one has a cold, one of the most common remedies is large dosages of fruit juice — especially citric juices? The most common answer is to supply the body with large amounts of Vitamin C to cure the cold. Is there a factual basis for that?

There are at least two studies that show that Vitamin C does not cure nor prevent the common cold. See Vitamin C for preventing and treating the common cold and Examining the evidence for the use of vitamin C in the prophylaxis and treatment of the common cold.

The juice therapy may be rooted in something really sensible — the need for fluids to break up the congestion. But fluids do not have to be in the form of fruit juices. Water, herbal infusions and brews, and soups are great too. Which is just as well because the truth is, I hate drinking citric juices when I have a cold because the acid makes my throat even more itchy and, when the cold is accompanied by a cough, and that is often the case with me, downing too much juice makes my cough even worse.

The even bigger truth is that there is no cure for the common cold. There are reliefs, certainly, like inhaling steam to relieve nasal congestion or saltwater gargles to relieve an itchy throat. Still most reliefs work in the form of a placebo.

So, does that mean we should just ignore Vitamin C in our daily diet? Well, no, of course not. We need it to stay healthy. Which now brings me to another common belief that the best sources of Vitamin C, or ascorbic acid, are acidic fruits. In fact, I know a lot of people who think that the more sour the fruit, the better source of Vitamin C it is. Ergo, a lemon has more Vitamin C than an orange, and so on, and so forth.

NOT TRUE. Some foods that don’t even have the slightest taste of acidity are even better sources of Vitamin C than sour fruits.

sources of Vitamin C

The table is from Wikipedia; countercheck the data with other sources if you feel that Wikipedia is not all that reliable. I did and I found pretty much the same things — peppers, broccoli and parsley contain more vitamin C than lemon and orange. See this and this, for instance. There are more but I’ll leave it to you to find them.

With all that in mind, I’ll stick to the Golden Rule for treating the common cold — sleep, rest, and more sleep and rest.

  • Sharon O

    I don’t know what it is but my tried and true remedy for providing SOME relief from a terrible cold or flu is having a cup of hot water with lemon juice in it and honey. That’s the juice of one lemon (at least) and as much or as little honey as you like (I like copious amounts of honey). Somehow the combination of the two works to make me feel instantly better. And I’ve given it to loved ones who also perk up after having it, so I’m convinced of its benefits! Do try it if you haven’t already Mrs V! Hope you feel better soon!

    • http://casaveneracion.com/ Connie Veneracion

      Oh I have — look! Very comforting. :)

      • Sharon O

        Ahh yes, you did a post about it being a comfort drink, but try it to ease your cold symptoms as well. Nina’s right too, the honey will make sure it goes down nicely and won’t make your throat feel itchier than it is. I drink a couple of cups when I’m feeling flu-ey and I swear the difference is remarkable :-)

        • http://casaveneracion.com/ Connie Veneracion

          I see. You sure it’s not a psychological thing? Any liquid can ease congestion.

      • Sharon O

        LOL at my avatar, he looks so aggro! :-D

      • Sharon O

        Like I said, I’ve given it to many loved ones and they’ve felt some relief as well. I’m not saying that it’s a cure, I’m saying that it can help to RELIEVE some of the horrible symptoms.

        I’ve stopped believing in what scientists have to say sometimes. You read one day that this thing is good for you, two days (or weeks, or years) later the same thing is completely bad! I mean, what the?

        I don’t think anyone knows for sure when it comes to the effectivness of Vitamin C to combat colds – but don’t knock those old wives’ tales, sometimes what becomes known and handed down for generations – ie what’s tried and true – is precisely that for a good reason!

        You’ll have to try this honey/lemon/hot water concoction to see for yourself I guess ;-) It’s up to you Mrs Connie. I was only trying to help :-D

        • http://casaveneracion.com/ Connie Veneracion

          Oh I know. I don’t believe in medical scientists either especially since their researches are often funded by pharmaceutical companies.

  • Nina

    Honey soothes itchythroat, too.

  • http://www.facebook.com/aarendal Albert ERT Rendal

    very useful tips, thanks Connie…. ???

    • http://www.facebook.com/aarendal Albert ERT Rendal

      used a musical icon but question marks came out, sorry about that.. :)